Medical Research

Why It Matters Which Doctor Performs Your IVF Transfer

As patients who endure the challenges of IVF know all too well that there are literally dozens of factors that contribute to the success of a given cycle, all of which culminate and converge on the embryo transfer. After dozens of injections, multiple blood draws, countless vaginal ultrasounds, and the egg retrieval, the embryo transfer procedure can feel sort of anti-climactic at times. However, there is evidence that transfer technique can influence the chance of achieving a pregnancy and a live birth, and that ultimately live birth rates vary by the doctor who is performing the transfer.

Doctors do many things to make sure the embryo is delivered to the right location and to ensure that it stays there. These include giving medications like progesterone to prevent small uterine contractions and using ultrasound to visualize the location of the transfer catheter during the procedure. Strong evidence also suggests that using soft transfer catheters and ultrasound guidance improve the chance of a successful transfer.

We at Reproductive Medicine Associates of New Jersey – a large academic private practice, which performs a large number of single blastocyst transfers after PGS – wanted to perform a study that determined how much the chance of achieving pregnancy and a live birth was influenced by the physician performing the transfer. To do so, we examined 2,707 embryo transfers performed by 11 doctors over a five-year period (2011 to 2015). To attempt to isolate the impact of the transferring doctor on the likelihood of success, we only considered the transfer of chromosomally normal embryos (as determined by PGS).

After controlling for a number of other factors, we observed that there was a significant difference in the likelihood of achieving pregnancy between the lowest performing doctor and the highest performing doctor. We observed that embryos transferred by the lowest performer resulted in a successful implantation 61.7% of the time, while the highest performer achieved implantation 73.5% of the time. More importantly, the possibility of achieving a live birth was also significantly different between the lowest and highest performer (50.6% vs. 66.4%).

So what does this mean for patients as they consider the many different offices and practice settings available? You obviously want to optimize every detail of your treatment cycle to give you the best chance of success. So, with the knowledge that embryo transfer technique does matter, are you better off pursuing care at a smaller clinic where you absolutely know which doctor will be performing your transfer? Or, are you better off at a bigger clinic with multiple doctors hoping that you end up with the highest performer?

The answer to this question is complicated. It is possible that smaller clinics are staffed by one or two doctors who excel at embryo transfer. However, it is equally likely that the transferring doctor at a solo practitioner clinic is well below average. The same possibilities exist in larger clinics with rotating schedules of “transfer doctor of the day.” Not every patient will be scheduled on the day that the top performer is in the office. However, one advantage of larger clinics who do internally track their success rates, is that comparatively high-achieving doctors can be identified and the factors that contribute to their success rates can be characterized. With this in mind, some practices have even videotaped the ultrasound image of the transfer procedure (with patients’ consent) to isolate the most important aspects of the high-performing doctors’ technique. The idea in this practice setting is that a rising tide will lift all boats.
In general, the embryo transfer success rates per doctor are not available to patients, as there is no regulatory requirement for offices to report these numbers. However, clinics who do track these indicators may have internal data available and it never hurts to ask for it. That being said, as was mentioned at the beginning of this post, a multitude of factors contribute to the likelihood of achieving pregnancy and delivering a healthy baby in a given cycle, and the embryo transfer procedure is just one of these.

Reviewing variation in success rates internally can be a painful reminder to individual doctors that we must be thoughtful about all aspects of fertility care. It’s often even more challenging to share these things in a public forum – like a national meeting or a publication. However, the hope at RMANJ is that being honest and forthright about variation in physician transfer success will not only improve the outcomes of the patients in our practice through honest self-assessment, but hopefully spur a wider discussion about the importance of quality control in general.

Expert's Perspective
Dr de Ziegler's Guide To Endometriosis
Dr. de Ziegler breaks down the misconceptions around surgery being the only way to diagnose endometriosis, weighs in on the decision between IVF and endometriosis surgery, and much more.
Expert's Perspective
When Is The ERA Test Appropriate?
The Endometrial Receptivity Assay is a test used by clinicians to discern when an embryo should be transferred to the uterus. The developmental state of the embryo and the uterine lining must be in sync for the embryo to implant. Here we look at the theory behind the ERA's usefulness and what the data implies about who, if anyone, should have the test performed.
Expert's Perspective
Treating East Asian Women For Infertility
East Asian women may metabolize estorgen differently and this may be the reason their rates of success tend to lag those of Caucasian women. This may add insight on the woman's choice of a fresh versus frozen transfer or how much gonadatropins to take.
Expert's Perspective
How We Might Treat South Asian Women Differently
As a field we're beginning to appreciate that women of different ethnicities may require unique treatment to achieve comparable outcomes. Here, Stanford professor Val Baker eluciates some of the nuances in treating women of a South Asian background.
Expert's Perspective
How Long Are Frozen Eggs and Embryos Good For?
IVF treatment is a relatively new treatment, and egg and embryo freezing are newer still. So do we know how long these gametes can be safely stored and still work?
Expert's Perspective
The Male Fertility Evaluation: Enhances Options and Signals of Future Health
20 - 25% of U.S. couples annually undergo IVF without having the male partner properly checked. This drives tens of thousands of unnecssary treatments, as well as needless cost and suffering. What's more, bypassing this crucial step causes us to miss a vital signal into that man's future health.
Expert's Perspective
Is it safe to ship cryopreserved eggs (and embryos)?
Patients are increasingly eager to ship their eggs and embryos to clinics out of town, out of state and out of the country. Vitrification has made that a far more delicate process. Peter Nagy, Ph.D helps explain the outcomes, steps and costs associated with shipping gametes from one clinic to another.
Expert's Perspective
Freeze Eggs or Embryos?
When the option to freeze embryos is available to patients, many disregard the option to freeze eggs. Owen Davis, ASRM President, weighs in on why egg freezing is still an important option to consider.
Expert's Perspective
From MacBooks to MAC Cosmetics: How Our Daily Routine Impacts Fertility
Dr. Cooper lays out the evidence on the products & habits that harm fertility, and realistic steps we can take to protect ourselves
Expert's Perspective
Improving IVF Success Rates: Using Low Oxygen in the Lab
Selecting a clinic is as much about selecting their laboratory as anything else. A key determinant of lab quality is the conditions they use to culture embryos. Using low oxygen in the incubator is preferable, yet a third of laboratories don't do this.
Expert's Perspective
Early Pregnancy Loss
Early pregnancy loss is the only focus of the team at Montefiore-Einstein in NYC. Here are some of their high-level observations on how to deal with the medical challenges.
+ Show More Articles
Personal Story
Why I Didn't Choose Reproductive Immunology After Miscarriage
After undergoing IVF for secondary infertility, Elissa was blindsided by a miscarriage of a PGS-tested normal embryo. She kept reading online about immunological causes and treatments, so she used her background in reporting to get to the bottom of the treatments behind the chatroom hype.
Personal Story
What We Never Expected About Reciprocal IVF
Christina and her wife Katie decided to bulid their family using Reciprocal IVF. Christina walks us through what turned out how they expected, and what didn't -- including the financial costs, choosing sperm donors, IVF success (and failure), recognition by the state, and having the outside world accept them as equal mothers.
Personal Story
Getting it Together After the Diagnosis: Making a Plan With Your Partner
Laura and her wife Sam always presumed they would need treatment to have a child, but the news Laura had fertility issues came as a surprise. Over the course of multiple cycles, and multiple years, they learned a number of crucial lessons.
Personal Story
Marriage & Male Infertility: Not on the Same Page and That’s O.K.
Men and women often deal differently with the emotional impact of infertility. How important is it for us to see everything the same way?
Personal Story
Twiblings: Being Pregnant During Surrogacy
Some hopeful mothers fear that having a child through surrogacy will be less special or intimate. For those who wonder, meet Nancy Rohde, who carried her own child, and had a baby through surrogacy, at the same time.
Personal Story
Wrangling With Reduction
Many patients undergoing fertility treatment ultimately need to grapple with the notion of whether it is safe to have a multiple pregnancy. Katie Ferraro talks about her decision not to selectively reduce during her quadruplet pregnancy.
+ Show More Articles
Medical Research
CRISPR, Gene Editing and IVF
Gene-editing in IVF made a big breakthrough this month and the CRISPR technology is now a reality. Here we catch up with Paula Amato and the team from Oregon Heath Sciences behind latest breakthrough.
Medical Research
The best starting point in treating PCOS? It’s not Clomid.
PCOS is responsible for 80% of cases where a woman isn't ovulting. A new study compared pregnancy success of clomiphene citrate (clomid) vs. letrozole (femara), with some strong results.
Medical Research
Weight Loss and IVF
The average American woman has a BMI in the high 20's. So for women undergoing IVF, with a BMI in the low-mid 30's, does weight loss improve rates of success? A team from Sweden ran a thoughtfully-conducted trial that offers up surprisingly complex answers.
Medical Research
IUI or IVF For Unexplained Infertility
Roughly 30% of infertility cases are labeled "unexplained," so how should patients decide between IUI vs IVF when we don't know the underlying issue? Here's one clue for a narrow subset of the newly-diagnosed "unexplained" population.
Medical Research
Does Your Clinic Influence If Your Embryos Are Good
Theoretically, the quality of your eggs and sperm should determine the quality of your embryos. However, this month we're reviewing data that shows which clinic you go to, and how they care for you and your embryos, could be a crucial determinant.
Medical Research
When IVF Babies Grow Up, Are They Healthy?
An Israeli study rigorously followed up with adults who were conceived via IVF, and compared their cognitive function, medical and mental health with naturally conceived peers. This is a unique study focusing on the long-term health of IVF babies and adults.
Medical Research
When One IVF Cycle Completes All Your Family Building Goals
For some IVF patients a single cycle can deliver two children through two pregnancies. For many Americans, two children is the ideal number. So who are the best candidates for "one-and-done" IVF in a safe and responsible manner?
+ Show More Articles