Medical Research

Is Freeze-Only Effective?

More and more frequently doctors recommend their IVF patients freeze all of their embryos before making a transfer. To the positive, the approach makes it easier to genetically-test the embryos, reduces rates of OHSS, and theoretically gives the endometrium time to recover and clinicians the chance to find the window when it's most receptive to receive the embryo.

On the other hand, freeze-only approaches are likely only as productive as the (wide variety of) laboratories handling the embryos, have been associated with "large for gestational age" offspring and likely add to the patient's total bill for that cycle.

Why This Study Was Special


Studies analyzing the value of freeze-only cycles have been extremely small in nature and performed at the hands of one or two clinicians at a single center. We just can’t say if their findings (which are supportive of freeze-only) apply to a broad group of fertility patients who will be treated at a spectrum of clinics (with varying degrees of laboratory freeze / thaw skill).

This study addresses a number of these shortcomings. It involves a large number of cycles (nearly 1,500 cycles, 3 - 10x more than we're accustomed to), performed on a broad variety of patients, treated at over 12 clinics and nicely matches the freeze-only group to a control group of patients that appear similar and who had a fresh embryo transfer.

What Was Tracked And What They Found


The investigators looked at Ongoing Pregnancy Rates (but not Live Birth Rates, a shortcoming) and found that patients who had freeze-only cycles outperformed their matched cohorts. However, the difference was only meaningful when the woman had a Progesterone level >1.0 ng/mL. At that level, or below, there was no statistical difference. It appears that within each Progesterone range, women ages 36 and above saw more benefit than women 35 and younger.

The Study’s Limitations


First, the study did not include an assessment of Live Birth Rate. Patients care about taking home a baby and so anything short of measuring this is probably incomplete. We’ve seen plenty of studies where therapies improve pregnancy rates but don’t improve actual take-home baby rates.

Second, the trial was not prospectively randomized and so we cannot be certain the groups being compared are in fact similar, or if the treatment is responsible for any difference in outcome we saw above.

Third, these patients were able to make multiple blastocysts and so what was seen may not apply to poor responders.

The Takeaway


Freeze-only is not equally helpful for all fertility patients. It's worth having a refined, data-driven discussion with your doctor about the benefits freeze-only confers and where (and for whom) it's yet to drive higher live birth rates.

You can see a more complete description of the data on fresh vs. frozen embryos here.

Related Lessons
Egg Freezing

Freezing Eggs vs. Embryos

IVF

Transferring Fresh or Frozen Embryos

Embryo Transfer

Frozen Embryo Transfer: Different Options To Prepare the Endometrium

IVF

Day 3 vs Day 5 Embryos

IVF

Which Embryo To Transfer?

Male Factor Infertility

Azoospermia

Lifestyle & Fertility

Body Fat and Fertility

Lifestyle & Fertility

BPA, Toxins, Pesticide and Phthalate Exposure

Intro For Gay Dads

Gay Dads: Picking The Right Clinic

Fertility 101

Getting Pregnant

IVF

Conventional Insemination or ICSI

IVF

Costs of IVF

IUI

Deciding Between IUI vs IVF

Endometriosis

Diagnosing Endometriosis

Fertility 101

Diagnosing Fertility Issues & Getting Help

Lifestyle & Fertility

Diet & Fertility

Acupuncture

Does Acupuncture Improve Outcomes?

Egg Freezing

Does Egg Freezing Work?

Lifestyle & Fertility

Exercise and Fertility

Lifestyle & Fertility

Fertility Impacts of Carbohydrates, Dairy, Meat, Fish, Soy & More

Fertility 101

Getting Pregnant Naturally

Acupuncture

Herbs and Fertility

Acupuncture

How Does Acupuncture Theoretically Address Fertility Challenges?

Fertility 101

How Fertility Treatments Address Our Problems

Embryo Transfer

How Many Embryos to Transfer?

Intro For Gay Dads

State Laws & Gay Fatherhood

IUI

How Well IUI Works By Patient Type

The IVF Lab

Measuring Lab Quality

Embryo Transfer

Improving Your Live Birth Rate Per Transfer

Fertility 101

Issues That Prevent Pregnancy

Male Factor Infertility

IVF, ICSI, IUI & Male Factor Infertility

IVF

IVF Success Rates

Egg Freezing

Knowing Whether You Should Freeze Eggs: Predicting Whether You’ll Have Trouble Conceiving

Male Factor Infertility

Lifestyle Factors & Their Impact on Male Factor Infertility

Intro For Gay Dads

Men Finding Egg Donors

Male Factor Infertility

Older Dads

IVF

Medication Protocols

Intro For Gay Dads

Overview: Men Having Babies

IVF

PGS Genetic Screening of Embryos

Male Factor Infertility

Reproductive Endocrinologists & Urologists

IVF

Risks of IVF

Lifestyle & Fertility

Smoking, Caffeine, Alcohol: Impacts On Fertility

IVF

Summary of The IVF Process

Male Factor Infertility

Testosterone, Hormone Imbalances, and Male Factor Infertility

Egg Freezing

Age & Egg Freezing

Genetic Screening

The Benefits of PGS

IUI

The Biggest Decisions In An IUI Cycle

Egg Freezing

The Importance of The Laboratory

Male Factor Infertility

The Semen Analysis

Endometriosis

Treating Endometriosis

Male Factor Infertility

Varicocele

Lifestyle & Fertility

Vitamins, Supplements & Fertility

Endometriosis

What Is Endometriosis?

Genetic Screening

What Is PGS?

Genetic Screening

What Is Mosaicism And Why Should I Care?