FertilityIQ DATA

2021 FertilityIQ Workplace Index

Methodology

Each year between November and March over 50,000 global FertilityIQ users provide copies of their employer's policy on family building coverage. FertilityIQ thereafter tallies, collates and scores employers based upon on multiple factors including broadness of benefit design, accessibility, flexbility for employee choice (e.g. nature of clinic networks), and ability to provide rigorous, non financially-conflicted education. For a full copy of the detailed report, please reach out to FertilityIQ.

Key Findings

8% Growth Amongst Large Employers

The number of large companies and employers that newly-introduced or enhanced their family-building (fertility, adoption, or foster) benefit grew 8% year-over-year and is now approaching 800 large organizations globally. New entrants, or those who raised their benefit, continued to hail from multiple verticals including retail, consumer packaged goods, industrial production, and healthcare services.

"Rise of the Rest"

Industries traditionally known for generous benefits (like technology, banking, and consulting) mostly decided not to increase their benefit. This is the second year in a row we’ve noted that “white-shoe” and "knowledge economy" verticals have decided to sit out the broad-based trend of improving benefits. Meantime, others have caught up. In our minds, the days when these industries could be viewed as undisputed, progressive leaders are rapidly coming to a close.

For context, industrial giant BP now offers benefits comparable to the household-name technology companies. Starbucks offers benefits on par with Goldman Sachs and Dressbarn offers benefits that resemble global auditor PWC.

Reduction of Benefits - A First

For the first time since we’ve covered the subject, in 2021 we saw a number of companies reduce benefits. Historically, we’d only seen benefit reductions in the context of an acquisition (like Walmart acquiring Jet). In 2021, reductions tended to come from employers with the most generous benefits and seemed to represent a rotation into helping cover more costly approaches like gestational surrogacy. This likely helps to broaden the set of employees who can build their families under the aegis of fertility treatment.

Total Fertility Coverage Largely Flat

The average amount of U.S. fertility coverage held steady at roughly $36,000 lifetime. This reflected a shift in companies expanding their existing benefits, new entrants coming in with lower introductory coverage and again, for the first time in years, companies reducing their benefits.

Adoption Dramatically Trails Fertility; LGBTQ Employees Most Impacted

This is the first year we’ve closely tracked coverage on adoption. Only 1 in 5 companies that offer fertility coverage also offer coverage for adoption or foster assistance. What’s more, the average levels of coverage amounted to around $8,000 per employee versus the $36,000 level allocated for fertility. For context, while only a few companies (like Nike, Johnson and Johnson, IBM) offered a $20,000 adoption benefit, over 200 companies offered a fertility benefit of the same amount or more.

We believe this has negative implications for many employees but especially for cis-gender men in same sex relationships, or those pursuing single fatherhood. In both of these cases, alternatives tend to include gestational surrogacy ($100,000 or more) or foster care, where the goal is to reunify a child with their family. We expect employers to take a harder look at this disparity in 2021 and beyond.

Egg Freezing Measured, Utility Brisk

In 2021 a number of large, Fortune 500 organizations introduced an elective egg freezing benefit. The range tended to be wide from $2,000 on the low end to multiple cycles on the high end. Companies struggled with how to treat the tax implications of elective egg freezing as many believe it’s not a “covered medical expense.” There is (possibly well placed) concern that those who’ve been treating it as such will need to re-audit financials, face fines or (in rare cases) restate earnings. We expect CFOs and auditors to pay more attention to the issue this year.

Relatedly, we believe egg freezing utilization was brisk in 2H20 and a function of COVID pent-up demand (reflecting clinic closures in 1H20), COVID-related difficulties of dating or finding a partner, and relocations away from partners. We ourselves see the uptick in interest reflected in FertilityIQ search data.

Scrutiny Over How Egg Freezers Are Educated

In our opinion, those considering egg freezing remain startlingly undereducated. The reality is most every stakeholder makes money when women freeze their eggs and do not when they don’t. Few entities have the time, resources or inclination to thoroughly educate women on the strengths and limitations (of which there are plenty of both) of the procedure.

We foresee 2021 as being the year companies closely examine what their employees are being told about the procedure given:

  1. Data tends to show that ~90% of egg freezers don't return to use their eggs
  2. A non-insignificant number (1 in 6) of egg freezers may come to regret the decision with a strong correlation between regret and the low level of balanced education they're afforded
  3. Tests (AMH and FSH) marketed on social media that tend to catalyze treatment do not predict whether a woman will have trouble conceiving naturally in the future

We foresee 2021 to be the first year CHROs, Benefit Managers (and their consultants) perform honest, unflinching reviews of (1) which organizations were hired to educate their people, (2) what precisely was (and was not) communicated and (3) what conflicts or motivations (financial or otherwise, conscious or otherwise) shaped how women were educated.

Extreme Difficulty Offering Benefits Overseas

For companies with a global footprint, and who want to offer benefits equitably to US and non-US employees alike, challenges remain. Regulation, legality, costs and access to care remain idiosyncratic within each country and this has stymied efforts amongst progressive employers to offer the same benefits across borders. For instance, multinationals offering egg freezing to US employees struggle to extend the same benefit to employees in China or Germany.

Related Courses

Adoption
Learn More
This course covers the crucial steps of domestic infant adoption, including the home study, locating expectant parents, validating the social medical history form, as well as preparing the hospital plan and post-adoption steps. We cover the total costs, timelines as well as crucial factors post-adoption.
67k
Egg Freezing
Learn More
Preparing you to be a confident self-advocate as you make decisions around fertility preservation.
Featuring experts from
Mount Sinai, NYU, +3 more
Becoming a Single Mother
Learn More
Fertility treatments, adoption and foster for solo mothers by choice.
Featuring experts from
Cornell, +7 more
6k
Fertility 101
Learn More
You took sex ed, but now you need to understand fertility. Data to answer your questions about natural conception and diagnosing what might be wrong.
Featuring experts from
Columbia, Cornell, +7 more
6k
Fertility for Black Families
Learn More
Black women and couples often have unique fertility challenges and in this course we'll address the more common underlying issues, ways in which they can be managed, rates of treatment success and the how IVF can be optimized to improve outcomes.
Featuring experts from
Johns Hopkins, +2 more
6k
Fertility For Lesbian Women Becoming Moms
Learn More
This is a course for those with a uterus who may identify as lesbian, bisexual, queer or otherwise partnered with someone of the same sex. We cover issues like selecting a sperm donor, doing an at-home insemination, or working with a fertility doctor for IUI, IVF, or using reciprocal IVF together with a partner.
Featuring experts from
Cornell, +1 more
Fertility for Military Families
Learn More
We discuss the basics of reproduction, fertility treatment, and the specific issues that affect military families like prolonged separation, exposure to toxins, and the importance of mental health care.
Featuring experts from
Stanford, Harvard, +3 more
Fertility for Patients of East Asian Heritage
Learn More
In this course, we cover the basics of fertility treatment (e.g. timed intercourse, oral medication, IUI, and IVF) as well as success rates and treatment nuances for women, couples and patients of East Asian heritage. We also highlight concepts and data as it pertains to acupuncture and mental health.
Featuring experts from
Harvard, UCSF, +7 more
Fertility for Patients of Latinx Heritage
Learn More
In this course, we cover "natural" conception, IUI, IVF, how success rates differ for Latinx patients as well as the impact of male factor, PCOS, and environmental exposures (e.g. pesticides, BPAs).
Featuring experts from
Harvard, Cornell, +5 more
Fertility for Patients of South Asian Heritage
Learn More
We cover the basics of fertility treatment (e.g. timed intercourse, oral medication, IUI and IVF) as well as studies, nuance and subjects that particularly pertain to women, couples, and patients of South Asian heritage.
Featuring experts from
Harvard, +8 more
Foster Parenting 101
Learn More
In this course, we'll cover the steps to starting the foster parenting process, how to help children who've suffered emotional and physical trauma, how to navigate transracial challenges, what the process looks like for single and LGBTQ individuals, and the process of adopting through the foster care system.
Gestational Surrogacy
Learn More
In this course, we cover rates of success as well as risks, alternatives, and critical choices for hopeful parents pursuing the gestational surrogacy process.
Featuring experts from
UCSF, +5 more
339k
IVF - In Vitro Fertilization
Learn More
The most complex fertility treatment, this course will help you do it right the first time.
Featuring experts from
Mount Sinai, Harvard, +7 more
5k
Paths to Parenthood For Single & Gay Dads: An Introduction
Learn More
Introducing the major decisions a gay couple or single man may face in order to become fathers. Tips on finding a clinic, selecting an egg donor & gestational carrier (surrogate), pros and con of twins, and costs involved. See an overview of adoption & foster care for gay and single dads.
Featuring experts from
Harvard, UCSF, +11 more
Trans Feminine Fertility
Learn More
Fertility guide for transfeminine people who were assigned male at birth. Covering how gender transition impacts fertility (including hormones like estrogen HRT & gender affirming surgery), fertility preservation strategies, and reproductive options for trans women. Resiliency & advocacy. Personal stories from trans women.
Featuring experts from
OHSU, +1 more
Trans Masculine Fertility
Learn More
Guide to fertility for trans men covering fertility impact of hormonal transition with testosterone, fertility preservation steps to consider before transitioning, and reproductive options for trans men from de-transitioning and conceiving naturally to IUI, IVF, or third-party reproduction like donor eggs or surrogacy.
Featuring experts from
OHSU, +2 more