Personal Story

Wrangling With Reduction

“Are you Catholic or Mormon?” As the oldest of six kids growing up in Southern California, I was used to comments from strangers about the unusually large size of our family. When my husband and I started trying for kids at the respective ages of 38 and 35, the odds seemed slim that we’d have our own abundant offspring to be ogled at. Well, three years and five healthy kids later, we can honestly say we never saw this situation coming. But our journey to becoming a large family has not come without some major hand wringing and difficult decision-making.

We have one singleton daughter conceived by IVF and infant quadruplets conceived with the aid of reproductive medication. When my husband, Charlie, and I found out we were expecting quadruplets, you can imagine our surprise. I had hoped for twins, was fearful about triplets, but never in a million years imagined carrying four babies.

But there was no real time to let the shock set in, as our physicians immediately started asking us about whether or not we would “selectively reduce”. All obstetricians want the healthiest outcome for mom and baby (…or babies), and the fewer babies you carry, the lower risk your pregnancy is. I was surprised to learn from a number of OBs that with quadruplets, the general recommendation is to selectively reduce down to two babies. A twin pregnancy is still high risk, but nothing in the realm of triplet or higher pregnancies. We were assured that a simple, painless procedure would eliminate two of the potential children we had hoped and prayed so hard to bring into the world.

In researching this selective reduction situation, Charlie and I kept hearing over and over that there is a 50 percent chance of severe handicap in quadruplets. The severe handicap risk is due almost entirely to the effects of premature labor. The average length of gestation in a quadruplet pregnancy is 28 weeks, which is basically three months shy of a full term pregnancy. And the fewer babies I could carry, ideally the longer I could stay pregnant. But at what cost?

Charlie and I had some of the hardest conversations of our life trying to wrangle with this idea of selective reduction. Fifty percent chance of severe handicap? I teach college kids, 50 percent is an F. Would it really be fair to try to bring four kids into the world knowing there’s a pretty good shot at least half of them will suffer? But on the other hand, there’s a 50 percent chance that they won’t. And what sort of amazing human beings are we foregoing if we make the wrong decision? How would life with disabled children affect our healthy older daughter, our marriage, and our finances?

For a week, we went back and forth between the ideas of twins versus quadruplets. Charlie and I are both practicing Catholics and we were forced to examine our faith and how we would cope with the outcome of either decision. Although we knew we dramatically increased the risk of a dangerous high-order multiples pregnancy when we made the decision to pursue fertility treatment, at the end of the day, we just did not feel it was our right to arbitrarily remove the life that science and God had joined hands in giving to us.

Eventually, against the recommendations of every specialist we had met with, Charlie and I decided against selective reduction. We pressed forward with the pregnancy and mentally prepared ourselves for life with four potentially severely handicapped children.

As 20 weeks of pregnancy stretched into 24, 28 and then 30, I started to accept that we might actually become quadruplet parents, and maybe this situation was not going to be so terrible. Our doctors discussed delivering no later than 34 weeks, although in the back of my head I never really believed we would make it that far. But low and behold, 34 weeks came and four beautiful babies were delivered by scheduled C-section, with over 30 attendants and specialists in the room for the delivery.

Charlie and I opted not to find out the genders ahead of time and we were overjoyed when our three boys and one girl quadruplets - Charlie, Claire, Henry and Dillon - all entered the world within one minute of each other and each weighing between 3 ½ and 4 pounds. They spent one month in the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) but had no major health issues, just requiring a few weeks’ time to learn to breathe, coordinate eating and grow.

Charlie, Claire, Henry and Dillon are now nine months old and are tracking well for their adjusted ages. There is no doubt that along with their big sister Molly, these kids are the center of our universe. And there is not a day that goes by where we don’t reflect on how glad we are we decided to ignore the initial advice to reduce.

Of course we are perfectly aware that the situation could have gone the other way and we have no reasonable explanation as to why we are so lucky. Understandably, many infertility stories do not end nearly as well…and perhaps another family would not have been so accepting of a similar quadruplet situation or considered it the blessing that we now do.

Our hope is that other families considering reduction will know there certainly is a happier side to the picture many pro-reduction OB specialists present. They claim to have evidence to back up their recommendations, but the sample size for triplet, quadruplet and higher order multiple births is so small compared to twins and singletons it is statistically insignificant. There are situations where sentiment can sometimes outweigh statistics and we feel so fortunate that we made the decision not to reduce.

Our fertility office staff members all wear the same shirts every Friday. The shirt features a bunch of babies bouncing off of curly-cue lines with the caption, “The path to parenthood is rarely straight.” Despite the roundabout way that we got here, we cannot imagine life without any of our babies. And we are proud to say that we have even gotten to the point where we welcome the weird comments and questions from perfect stranger bystanders. Now, to the “Are you Catholic or Mormon?” question, we just answer…, “We’re crazy!”

Expert's Perspective
Fertility for Black Patients: Expert Interview

We were honored to interview Dr. McCarthy-Keith, Medical Director at Shady Grove Fertility Atlanta, on topics pertaining to Black families & fertility patients. In addition to sharing valuable insights, Dr. McCarthy-Keith answered questions from members of the community.

Expert's Perspective
Improving IVF Success Rates: Using Low Oxygen in the Lab

Selecting a clinic is as much about selecting their laboratory as anything else. A key determinant of lab quality is the conditions they use to culture embryos. Using low oxygen in the incubator is preferable, yet a third of laboratories don't do this.

Expert's Perspective
Freeze Eggs or Embryos?

When the option to freeze embryos is available to patients, many disregard the option to freeze eggs. Owen Davis, ASRM President, weighs in on why egg freezing is still an important option to consider.

Expert's Perspective
Is it safe to ship cryopreserved eggs (and embryos)?

Patients are increasingly eager to ship their eggs and embryos to clinics out of town, out of state and out of the country. Vitrification has made that a far more delicate process. Peter Nagy, Ph.D helps explain the outcomes, steps and costs associated with shipping gametes from one clinic to another.

Expert's Perspective
From MacBooks to MAC Cosmetics: How Our Daily Routine Impacts Fertility

Dr. Cooper lays out the evidence on the products & habits that harm fertility, and realistic steps we can take to protect ourselves

Expert's Perspective
Early Pregnancy Loss

Early pregnancy loss is the only focus of the team at Montefiore-Einstein in NYC. Here are some of their high-level observations on how to deal with the medical challenges.

Expert's Perspective
The Male Fertility Evaluation: Enhances Options and Signals of Future Health

20 - 25% of U.S. couples annually undergo IVF without having the male partner properly checked. This drives tens of thousands of unnecssary treatments, as well as needless cost and suffering. What's more, bypassing this crucial step causes us to miss a vital signal into that man's future health.

Expert's Perspective
How Long Are Frozen Eggs and Embryos Good For?

IVF treatment is a relatively new treatment, and egg and embryo freezing are newer still. So do we know how long these gametes can be safely stored and still work?

Expert's Perspective
How We Might Treat South Asian Women Differently

As a field we're beginning to appreciate that women of different ethnicities may require unique treatment to achieve comparable outcomes. Here, Stanford professor Val Baker eluciates some of the nuances in treating women of a South Asian background.

Expert's Perspective
Treating East Asian Women For Infertility

East Asian women may metabolize estorgen differently and this may be the reason their rates of success tend to lag those of Caucasian women. This may add insight on the woman's choice of a fresh versus frozen transfer or how much gonadatropins to take.

Expert's Perspective
When Is The ERA Test Appropriate?

The Endometrial Receptivity Assay is a test used by clinicians to discern when an embryo should be transferred to the uterus. The developmental state of the embryo and the uterine lining must be in sync for the embryo to implant. Here we look at the theory behind the ERA's usefulness and what the data implies about who, if anyone, should have the test performed.

Expert's Perspective
Dr de Ziegler's Guide To Endometriosis

Dr. de Ziegler breaks down the misconceptions around surgery being the only way to diagnose endometriosis, weighs in on the decision between IVF and endometriosis surgery, and much more.

+ Show More Articles
Medical Research
What Mosaicism Means for Live Birth Rates

New data compares results transferring different types of mosaic embryos, with surprising outcomes.

Medical Research
IUI Success Rates Doubled With Endometrial Scratch

Medicated IUI success rates remain stubbornly low with live birth rates often around 10% per cycle. Investigators determined whether incorporating endometrial scratch bolsters IUI success rates. For the moment, it appears so.

Medical Research
Why It Matters Which Doctor Performs Your IVF Transfer

According to FertilityIQ data, 70% of patients have a different doctor perform their embryo transfer. Scott Morin & Eric Forman of RMA New Jersey study to what extent that matters.

Medical Research
When One IVF Cycle Completes All Your Family Building Goals

For some IVF patients a single cycle can deliver two children through two pregnancies. For many Americans, two children is the ideal number. So who are the best candidates for "one-and-done" IVF in a safe and responsible manner?

Medical Research
When IVF Babies Grow Up, Are They Healthy?

An Israeli study rigorously followed up with adults who were conceived via IVF, and compared their cognitive function, medical and mental health with naturally conceived peers. This is a unique study focusing on the long-term health of IVF babies and adults.

Medical Research
Does Your Clinic Influence If Your Embryos Are Good

Theoretically, the quality of your eggs and sperm should determine the quality of your embryos. However, this month we're reviewing data that shows which clinic you go to, and how they care for you and your embryos, could be a crucial determinant.

Medical Research
IUI or IVF For Unexplained Infertility

Roughly 30% of infertility cases are labeled "unexplained," so how should patients decide between IUI vs IVF when we don't know the underlying issue? Here's one clue for a narrow subset of the newly-diagnosed "unexplained" population.

Medical Research
Weight Loss and IVF

The average American woman has a BMI in the high 20's. So for women undergoing IVF, with a BMI in the low-mid 30's, does weight loss improve rates of success? A team from Sweden ran a thoughtfully-conducted trial that offers up surprisingly complex answers.

Medical Research
The best starting point in treating PCOS? It’s not Clomid.

PCOS is responsible for 80% of cases where a woman isn't ovulting. A new study compared pregnancy success of clomiphene citrate (clomid) vs. letrozole (femara), with some strong results.

Medical Research
CRISPR, Gene Editing and IVF

Gene-editing in IVF made a big breakthrough this month and the CRISPR technology is now a reality. Here we catch up with Paula Amato and the team from Oregon Heath Sciences behind latest breakthrough.

Medical Research
The Impact of Sugar, Soda and Caffeine on IVF

The team at Brigham & Women's Hospital in Boston reveals surprising results on how sugar, soda and caffeine each impact (or don't) oocyte numbers and ultimate IVF success rates.

+ Show More Articles